Every few months, yet another democracy campaign launches with the same ingredients: a sober tone, a stack of statistics and a call to remember what’s at stake. Most of them are well-intentioned — and most of them reach the people who were already worried.

On Oct. 22, Spitfire gathered Joe Kennedy, founder of The Team; Tova Wang, Harvard’s Ash Center; and Evan Weissman, founder of Warm Cookies of the Revolution for a conversation we called “Not Another Democracy PSA.” The premise was simple: The pro-democracy movement has spent years perfecting its arguments. Unfortunately, the arguments are not the problem.

The problem is belonging.

Think about your favorite sports team, performer or brand. You don’t have to be persuaded to care about what they share: You inherit a community, a set of rituals, a badge to wear and a seat next to strangers who feel like family. The identity comes first, and the participation follows. Democracy asks people to participate, and at most, you can expect a sticker to show that you voted. The result: Nineteen million people attended NFL regular season games each year, while 7 million attended No Kings rallies.

Together with Joe, Tova and Evan, we reimagined what it would look like for civic life to work more like fandom and what communicators, funders and organizations can do to make it happen.

Three takeaways

1. Go where audiences already are.

Start with what people already care about — whether it’s soccer, Marvel movies or running — and then build from that to create experiences that engage people in civic participation. Joe and The Team’s approach includes the pizza-fueled Virtual All-Star Meeting, which features pro athletes, that they refer to as “civic tailgating.” 

2. Build community, and then weave in the issues you want people to care about.

Tova said, “The most politically diverse place at any given moment in the United States is an NFL stadium on Sunday.” She told us how the Las Vegas Raiders stadium became a polling location in 2024 with a full fan experience around it. It became the most popular voting location. Its voters skewed younger and were more often first-time voters, with no partisan advantage. The Raiders are repeating it this year, with a follow-up survey planned.

3. Lead with fun.

Evan noted that his team’s competition is church, Netflix and the NFL. That’s why they’ve organized 40+ arts-based programs, including the Tax Day Carnival, The Huddle (a series of policy talks held at breweries during “halftimes” of football games), a neighborhood Olympics, and civic bingo and game nights. 

What this means for communicators

If belonging is the missing ingredient, our task as communicators changes: Instead of asking how to make the case for democracy more persuasive, we should ask how to build the identity, rituals and shared spaces that make participation feel natural.

That points to a few questions any organization can ask of its own work:

  • Are we offering people a reason to engage or a place to belong?
  • Who are the trusted messengers our audience already follows, and are we working with them or around them?
  • What would our work look like if we designed it for others to join, not just understood?

This has been a focus of my work with Spitfire for clients like Hip Hop Caucus, whom we worked with to place music culture back at the center of its work, and the BIPOC Arts Network and Fund that we rebranded and renamed as Houston in Color.

Keep the conversation going

If you missed the webinar, you can watch the full recording below.

And if you’re working on belonging, culture or civic engagement from the sports, brand, philanthropy or organizing side, I’d like to hear from you. You can email me at mcrawford@spitfirestrategies.com.